07 Aug 2022

COMMENT: Kildare’s glass: half full or half empty?

Tommy Callaghan gives his views

COMMENT: Kildare’s glass: half full or half empty?

Kildare Captain Eoin Doyle takes a high tackle from Longford Barry McKeon during the Leinster GAA Football Championship Quarter Final played at Tullamore on Sunday, May 26 PIC: Sean Brilly

Not for the first time we have seen the Jekyll and Hyde side of Kildare.

Most of us have lived with it all our lives and as we saw on Sunday in O’Connor Park, nothing, if anything has changed.

Favs tag once again sat pretty uncomfortable on Kildare shoulders.

If anything, The Lilies quarter final clash with Longford only emphasised that fact.

Four points clear after eight minutes.

Level after 14.

One behind after 20 minutes.

Level after 21..

Two behind after 21 minutes.

Level after 27.

Four clear at half time.

And that was with the strong wind in The Lilies favour.

For those not in Tullamore it sounds exciting, close and decent.

For those at it though it was far from it.

Dominant at times.

Under pressure at times.

Attack-wise decent.

Defensive-wise poor in the extreme.

Seven points in the clear after 42 minutes.

Incredibly just one point in front on 57.

That lead pushed out to three with 59 minutes on the clock.

Yet when the full time whistle arrived the sides were level.

Talk about pulling one’s hair out.

If you had hair that is.

That auld chestnut that Kildare can’t kill off teams is evident again.

It’s a fair few years ago now since Kieran McGeeney told Kildare players at his very first gathering that The Lilies are looked upon as a lovely team to play against as they play nice football but have no bottle; no ruthlessness; no killer instant.

That statement raised its ugly head once again on Sunday.

And so to extra time.

Lilies kick on again.

Four minutes in, against the wind, three clear.

Five minutes in Kildare lead back to two.

Eight minutes in the lead pushed out to three again.

Then just before the break sides level following Longford’s third goal.

Still, Lilies in strong position.

Wind in their favour for extra time second half.

But Kildare failed to raise another flag.

As did Longford.


Absolutely incredible.

Many questions.

Attack-wise much improvement but when goal chances are made they just have to be finished off; not to do so will simply come back to haunt them. Midfield in and out (again). Defence looked jittery and uneasy.

Three goals conceded against Longford is three too many.

One of those goals in particular would give one nightmares.

Adam Tyrrell impressive until forced off injured.

How bad?

Who knows.

Kicking the ball around at the extra time break nevertheless.

Ben McCormack, our second main threat, withdrawn at half time.

Re-appears in extra time to score a point.

Head scratching.


Next Sunday, replay; same venue; an hour earlier.

Fasten your seat belts for another 70 minutes plus of ecstasy and agony.



Sitting still, doing nothing, will surely produce the same performance.

Mick O’Grady probably ready to return.

Tommy Moolick due a start.


Jimmy Hyland in the same situation.

Kildare glass half full or half empty?

Hard to say.

One way or the other the glass is leaking and unless that is mended, it will be off to Netwatch Cullen Park and Carlow in the Qualifiers instead of Croke Park and The Dubs.

Despite what many may be thinking, Croke Park is where Kildare must aim for.


To continue reading this article for FREE,
please kindly register and/or log in.

Registration is absolutely 100% FREE and will help us personalise your experience on our sites. You can also sign up to our carefully curated newsletter(s) to keep up to date with your latest local news!

Register / Login

Buy the e-paper of the Donegal Democrat, Donegal People's Press, Donegal Post and Inish Times here for instant access to Donegal's premier news titles.

Keep up with the latest news from Donegal with our daily newsletter featuring the most important stories of the day delivered to your inbox every evening at 5pm.